Thursday, April 3, 2025
Google search engine
HomeHealthLASIK Technology Comparison: Features & Benefits

LASIK Technology Comparison: Features & Benefits

LASIK technology has gradually evolved significantly over the years, enhancing precision, safety, and patient outcomes. The origin of LASIK is as old as it is traced back to Dr Jose Ignacio Barraquer, a Spanish ophthalmologist who pioneered the idea for the very first time in the 1950s. His idea of reshaping the cornea to correct vision inspired further research by experts, including Dr. Stephen Trokel from the USA, who played a key role in advancing laser vision correction techniques. Dr. Trokel worked on excimer laser technology, which became the basis of modern refractive surgeries like PRK and LASIK. 

In the 1980s, researchers developed the concept of reshaping the cornea using a laser, building upon earlier techniques like keratomileusis and photorefractive keratectomy (PRK). Apart from all the above ideas, the credit goes to Dr. Ioannis Pallikaris, a Greek ophthalmologist who successfully performed the LASIK eye surgery for the first time.

Dr. Ioannis Pallikaris
Dr. Ioannis Pallikaris

In this article, several best and latest LASIK technologies have been compared across different platforms (excimer lasers, femtosecond lasers, and tracking systems), with multiple brands offering variations. The choice depends on factors like eye structure, corneal thickness, and surgeon preference:

1. Femtosecond Lasers (For Bladeless LASIK Flap Creation)

Femtosecond Lasers
Femtosecond Lasers

In this procedure, femtosecond lasers create the corneal flap without using a mechanical blade (microkeratome). It uses infrared (IR) light, typically around 1053 nm. Surgeons use it in the first step to create the corneal flap before reshaping. Therefore, the result of femtosecond is more precise and safer than traditional microkeratomes. Details of common technologies related to femtoseconds are discussed in the table below:

TechnologyManufacturerFlap PrecisionAdvantages
IntraLase FSJohnson & JohnsonHigh precisionReduces flap complications, customizable thickness
Zeiss VisuMaxCarl Zeiss MeditecExtremely preciseEnables SMILE procedure, gentle on the cornea
Ziemer FEMTO LDVZiemer Ophthalmic SystemsUltra-thin flapsUses low-energy pulses for less tissue damage

2. Excimer Lasers (For Corneal Reshaping)

Excimer Lasers
Excimer Lasers

Excimer lasers have a very essential role in LASIK eye surgery. The function of the excimer laser is to reshape the cornea to correct refractive errors. It uses ultraviolet (UV) light, typically around 19 nm. It is used in the second step of LASIK to correct vision after the corneal flap has been created. The result of the excimer laser is highly precise in tissue removal, minimizing thermal damage. Details of common technologies are discussed in the table below:

TechnologyManufacturerFeaturesAdvantages
VISX Star S4 IRJohnson & JohnsonIris recognition, ActiveTrak 3D eye trackingHigh precision, reduces night glare
Allegretto WaveLightAlconWavefront optimization, 400Hz repetition rateFast treatment time, smooth corneal surface
Schwind AmarisSchwind Eye-Tech Solutions7D eye tracking, SmartPulse TechnologyHigh-speed ablation, customized treatments
NIDEK EC-5000NIDEKMulti-zone ablation profilesSuitable for high prescriptions
Technolas TENEO 317Bausch + LombSmartScan technology, high-speed treatmentAccurate and fast corneal reshaping

3. Custom LASIK (Wavefront-Guided LASIK)

Custom LASIK (Wavefront-Guided LASIK)

Custom LASIK utilizes advanced mapping technology to tailor laser treatment based on individual eye characteristics:

TechnologyManufacturerFeaturesBest For
WaveLight Contoura VisionAlcon22,000 corneal elevation points mappedHigher-order aberrations, sharper vision
VISX CustomVueJohnson & JohnsonWaveScan digital mappingNight vision improvement, personalized treatment
Schwind Amaris 1050RSSchwind7D eye tracking, high-speed laserHigh precision, suitable for thin corneas

4. Specialized LASIK Technologies

i. Topography-Guided LASIK

Topography-Guided LASIK
Topography-Guided LASIK

Corrects corneal irregularities based on a topographic scan.

TechnologyManufacturerBest For
Contoura VisionAlconIrregular corneas, reducing halos and glare
Schwind AmarisSchwindComplex corneal conditions

ii. SMILE (Small Incision Lenticule Extraction)

The purpose of the SMILE procedure is to treat myopia (-1.00 to -10.00 D) and astigmatism (up to -5.00 D). It is a minimally invasive alternative to LASIK, avoiding flap creation.

TechnologyManufacturerAdvantages
Zeiss VisuMaxCarl Zeiss MeditecNo flap needed, minimal dry eye risk

iii. Presby LASIK

Designed to correct presbyopia (age-related near vision loss) using multifocal laser patterns.

TechnologyManufacturerBest For
SupracorBausch + LombAge-related near vision correction

5. Eye-Tracking & Pupil-Centering Technologies

Enhance LASIK precision by adjusting for eye movements.

TechnologyManufacturerFunction
ActivTrakVISX Star S4 IR3D eye tracking
Fast TrackAlcon WaveLightHigh-speed movement detection
7D Eye TrackingSchwind AmarisMonitors head tilt and pupil shift

Conclusion:

After a detailed discussion, it might be difficult to consider the best and most relevant LASIK technology. Ultimately, the surgeon has the choice to decide which technology is best according to the patient’s condition. Moreover, the best treatment based on patient needs is discussed here:

  • Best overall precision → Alcon WaveLight Contoura Vision (customized treatment)
  • Best for thin corneas → Schwind Amaris 1050RS
  • Best for minimal dry eye risk → Zeiss VisuMax SMILE
  • Best for presbyopia (age-related vision loss) → Supracor Presby LASIK

LASIK technology is still heading towards advancement while remaining the most effective vision correction procedures. If choosing the right technology ensures optimal results.

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -
Google search engine

Most Popular

Recent Comments